47%: The Liberal Goal

Recently, all the big political news has been about Romney’s 47% comments.

It has already been noted that this is true, the vast majority of federal income taxes are paid by the rich, while almost half pay noting. Even liberal “fact-checkers” don’t disagree.

Some liberals quibble that the poor pay comparatively more in payroll taxes, but this is a fallacious comparison, as payroll taxes are specifically designated to social security, unemployment insurance, and medicare. These are not general taxes (or at least shouldn’t be), they are taxed premiums dedicated to providing  insurance and retirement guarantees and should be treated as such. Comparing payroll taxes to general taxation is idiotic.


Everybody reading this already knows that a society where more than half the people do not contribute to general taxation and a significant population receive more in government benefits than are contributing can not sustain itself for long. Eventually the ability to pay for bread and circuses collapses.

The US is on it’s way there. 1/16 people are on disability, 1/7 on food stamps, and almost alf of people receive some sort of government benefits. Half of young workers are either unemployed or underemployed. In addition, the government controls about 2/5 of the economy and 1/5 of the employed work for the the government. Almost half of people don’t pay income taxes.  And government  is growing.

That’s not what I want to talk about today. If you can’t figure out why this is unhealthy for society, I’m not quite sure what I could say to convince you.


It has also been noted that getting people dependent on government is the liberal strategy and has been the liberal strategy since FDR.

So why are liberals so angry over Romney’s quote, when it’s been their strategy for decades?

For exactly that reason; they do not want people to understand their strategy. Liberalism is the ideology of the state; that is all the various interests that make up liberalism have in common. For a core of elite individuals, the expansion of the state is their reason d’etre. Their purpose is the Gramscianslow march through culture” to destroy traditional “oppressive” institutions and replace it with the state.

But pointing that the expansion of the state is the goal, harms their ability to expand the state. They can’t come right out and say their purpose in the anglosphere. Englishmen are culturally suspicious of and hostile towards the state and inclined towards classical liberalism or liberal conservatism, with American Englishmen being the most hostile.

Even most liberals do not agree with the end goal of the Gramscian march. They are mostly decent people (ie: the “useful idiots“) who want to help the poor (or some other cause) but are either too lazy, too soft-hearteded, and/or too misinformed to realize the final outcomes of the policies they propose.

So, the left-liberals  can not come out and say their true goals, which is the expansion of the state. So, they cloak their desire to expand the state behind other justifications: keynesian economics, feminism, anti-poverty, anti-racism, the environment, equality, etc.

No matter what justification they use or what problem they say they want to solve, though, the answer is always the same: expand the state.

And the the useful idiots all line up in support.


The Gramscian strategy works well. Each time the government expands, it is almost impossible to destroy that expansion in the future, so you only have to take it a bit at a time. A temporary expansion here and a minor intrusion there and eventually the government controls half the economy. As the government takes over more control of life, opportunities to live life outside government decrease. Individuals become increasingly dependent on government at levels they themselves don’t even realize. Eventually, the government becomes the only thing holding society together, however poorly.

The government begins to replace parents, it replaces family, it replaces local charity, it replaces local churches, it replaces local community. Eventually,  it replaces the entirety of civil society.

If you want to see the end state of the Gramscian march, simply look at the black community in the US. Their families are destroyed, most of their children grow up without a father, a large proportion of their males end up criminals, dependence on the state is high, and their civil society is destroyed. The black community has been destroyed by the welfare society government has put onto it.

And guess what, blacks vote almost entirely Democrat, the party that fought for their enslavement and for Jim Crow, just so the state benefits that are destroying them keep flowing.


The left- liberal ideologues are intent on forcing the government on you, so that you become dependent on it, so you will support government’s further intrusion into and control of your life. That is and has been their strategy for decades.

They want you dependent.

Romney simply pointed out the results of the strategy. This is why they are attacking him so violently, because once you know that government dependency is, you might ask why it is.
If you ask why it is, you might understand their strategy. Once you understand their strategy, you might resist it.

So, the question is, do you want to be dependent on government as they manipulate you?

14 responses to “47%: The Liberal Goal

  • Tim

    Excellent post, as ever.

    I do wonder how we can convince more people to take charge of their own lives and not ask for, or expect, handouts from the government.

  • Cogitansiuvenis

    I am afraid that we may not be able to convince these individuals; only the school of hard knocks will teach them this lesson. I think the best thing we can do is, much like masons, find parts of our cultural foundation that is salvagable, and ensure that these do not degrade so that we can rebuild from there.

    One thing is for certain is that we need to keep up with our efforts and pointing out the logical and intellectual fallacies of the statist. When the ‘event’ comes we have one of two directions that we can go. We can either take the path of Domition and further increase the power of the state, or we can to the path that our forefathers took and embrace freedom. I am under no illusions that our statist brethren will find a way to blame the events as ‘failures of too much freedom’. Though of course they will word it differently.

    I hope Mr. Paul still draws breath when this happens because he is perhaps the best individual to advocate the cause of freedom during the next crisis. He has predicted it for years and no one can deny his tireless advancement of liberty. Men like him will be the best intelelctual soldiers to fight for the minds of the people in the near future.

  • Free Northerner

    Sadly, I don’t think the old guard like Paul and Buchanan will be around when (if) the collapse comes, but sometimes I think you’re right, I’m not sure if we will ever wean the public off the government’s teat without something major happening.

  • The Collapse « Free Northerner

    […] Yesterday, I noted that government takeover and the collapse of the family from the “long march through culture” led to what you see in black America: high dependence on government, high violence, social problems, etc. […]

  • State Sponsored | The Hunt

    […] The state still even partially supports her. So if you pay taxes, congratulations you’re subsidizing her and her kids. Separately. It’s a sad story and my part in it is small, but it serves as a […]

  • Linkage Is Good For You: I Have Arrived | Society of Amateur Gentlemen

    […] Free Northerner – Lightning Round, Lessons From Dating A Fashion Model, The Collapse, 47%: The Liberal Goal […]

  • Demanding More « Free Northerner

    […] Simply put, there are no longer any guarantees that hard-work and responsibility will lead to a worthwhile job. But even if he eventually gets a job, he is punished by having half his income is taken by the state and given to the irresponsible. […]

  • The Squeeze and the Surrogate Family « Free Northerner

    […] hope those who did this feel it was worth it. Do you think it […]

  • It’s all Related « Free Northerner

    […] became increasingly accepted in certain circles, until the 1960′s and 1970′s, when the long march through culture triumphed. Progressive ideology was wholly taken over by those denying the existence human nature and over […]

  • American’s Deserve to Get What They Want « Free Northerner

    […] the current number being used is) wage differential pales in economic significance to the other economic woes facing the US. The near doubling of the unemployment rate since 2008 combined with a full 2% of the population […]

  • Obliviousness, Incivility, and the Destruction of the Old Order « Free Northerner

    […] women under the label of feminism and a small, but vocal minority under the banner of affiliated progressive ideologies decided they did not care for civilization and its constraints. They rebelled against it and fought […]

  • Matthew Yglesias is an Idiot | Free Northerner

    […] to a liberal shill. The definition of a good government program is any that increases the power of government but does not inconvenience a vulgar Keynesian or a friend of the […]

  • The Problem of Natural Slaves | Free Northerner

    […] government benefits while the government controls 41% of the economy, and still the natural slaves demand more government and more dependence. While the US is self-destructing, the natural slaves debate frivolities. Most of the rest of the […]

  • MGTOW, MRA, and the Long March | Free Northerner

    […] written on the long march before and how the progressivists goal is to have us dependent on the state, how the alt-right, manosphere, and their issues are all related and at war with progressive […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: